Posted by
glen ropella on
URL: http://friam.383.s1.nabble.com/Slasdhot-linked-article-RE-god-tp7585918p7585924.html
Re: clique preservation, I keep finding myself wondering if we're
shooting ourselves in the foot calling these acts "terrorism" and the
actors "terrorists". It seems to me these are just criminals. If you
buy the Dawkins/Harris/Maher line about Islam being more violent than
other religions, then perhaps these "new" categories (like "enemy
combatant" and "terrorist") might make sense. But if you don't buy that
(like me) and tend to think any person is capable of massive destruction
given the right circumstances, then such categories don't make as much
sense.
Granted, _if_ these people were rational and strategic and were
committing these acts purposefully to instill terror, then it makes
sense and the actors would sometimes commit other, more mainstream acts
(crimes, acts of war, etc that are not terrorism). But it's difficult
to buy the argument that these guys (or Tsarnaev and the like) are
rational. I can see someone thinking of bin Laden as rational and a
terrorist. But these guys seem more like fever-eyed lunatics to me.
The same issue comes up w.r.t. gitmo and justifications for suspending
due process. If the US were really more focused on integration, then
wouldn't we treat people like this as criminals and not terrorists?
On 01/08/2015 02:36 PM, Owen Densmore wrote:
> The big issue Europe, and France in particular faces, is "multiculturalism"
> vs "cultural integration". The US is structured to favor the latter.
> Europe the former.
>
> The co-existence approach (multiculturalism) can in the worst of cases lead
> to ghettos and isolation, leading to anger and hate.
>
> I have zero idea if this is part of the apparent (and definitely not real)
> perception that islam, rather than islamic nut cases, is the cause of the
> current violence.
--
⇔ glen
============================================================
FRIAM Applied Complexity Group listserv
Meets Fridays 9a-11:30 at cafe at St. John's College
to unsubscribe
http://redfish.com/mailman/listinfo/friam_redfish.com